Welcome to Mystic Market Kitchen and Eatery
At Mystic Market Kitchen and Eatery, we believe food is more than sustenance; it's an experience. Nestled in the heart of Old Saybrook, our café embraces culinary creativity, offering a delightful menu that caters to everyone—from families to food enthusiasts. With a commitment to quality and flavor, our dishes highlight fresh, local ingredients, ensuring each bite resonates with authenticity. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or enjoying our cozy outdoor seating, our welcoming atmosphere fosters connection over good food. Join us at Mystic Market, where every meal is crafted to create lasting memories in a vibrant community setting.
- 70 Mill Rock Rd E Old Saybrook, CT 06475 United States Hotline: (860) 661-5910
Welcome to Mystic Market Kitchen and Eatery, a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Old Saybrook, Connecticut. This specialty food café is more than just a place to grab a bite; it’s a culinary experience that promises to engage your senses and satisfy your cravings.
Located at 70 Mill Rock Rd E, Mystic Market Kitchen and Eatery seamlessly blends a warm, inviting atmosphere with a diverse menu that caters to a variety of tastes. From their vibrant outdoor seating area to the welcoming interior, it’s the perfect spot for gatherings, whether you’re meeting friends for a light lunch or enjoying a family dinner.
- Takeout & Delivery: Craving a delicious meal at home? Mystic Market offers convenient takeout and delivery options that ensure you can enjoy their culinary delights wherever you are.
- Reservations: For those special occasions, don’t forget to reserve your spot! The café tends to fill up quickly, especially during peak hours.
- Kid-Friendly: The menu is also designed with families in mind, making it a great choice for kids of all ages.
- Good for Groups: If you’re dining with a larger party, the spacious seating arrangements are perfect for group gatherings.
- Free Wi-Fi: Stay connected while you eat—ideal for casual meetings or catching up on your favorite shows.
Mystic Market Kitchen and Eatery excels in creating dishes that are not only visually appealing but also bursting with flavor. Each bite tells a story, from fresh salads to comforting entrees that echo seasonal inspirations. The use of local ingredients shines through and fosters a connection to Connecticut's rich culinary heritage.
What struck me the most was the harmonious blend of flavors in their signature dishes. For instance, the combination of fresh herbs and spices in their pasta dishes captivates the palate, leaving a lingering taste that beckons a return visit. The café's commitment to quality is evident in every aspect, including their well-curated selection of beverages, including a variety of alcoholic options to complement your meal.
In addition to their fantastic food, the ambiance strikes a perfect balance. Moderate noise levels create a lively atmosphere without being overwhelming, making it ideal for both casual meals and celebratory dinners. On-site parking and bike parking options further enhance accessibility, making experiencing Mystic Market Kitchen and Eatery a breeze.
If you’re in Old Saybrook, a visit to Mystic Market Kitchen and Eatery isn't just recommended; it’s essential. Whether it's the inviting environment, delectable food, or the friendly service, this eatery embodies the essence of community dining, making every meal a memorable experience. So, bring your friends and family, grab a seat, and immerse yourself in the flavors that this charming café has to offer!
For more information or to make your reservation, give them a call at (860) 661-5910.

Thanksgiving 2024- first time ordering an entire meal....we would do it again. Suprisingly pleased with the whole bird....all sides delicious and plentiful....carrot cake for dessert was amazing. Also bought soups and a couple of prepared meals for the next day- all very good. Only negatives....rolls were average and the pickup time exceeded 30 minutes- yikes! Lots of counter staff just standing waiting for customers to come in- should bave been directed to go in back kitchen to assist with packaging of Tgiving meals to go!

This is the perfect place for a healthy lunch. The lemon orzo and the kale and mango salad was excellent. Also enjoyed the clam chowder. We are from California and this was the best food we had today !