Mystic Market Kitchen and Eatery Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Mystic Market Kitchen and Eatery, where culinary creativity meets comfort in a cozy café atmosphere. Located in the heart of Old Saybrook, Connecticut, this charming eatery offers a vibrant menu that showcases an array of specialty dishes, perfect for any palate.
- Seasonal Freshness: The menu bursts with seasonal ingredients, ensuring every bite is as fresh as it is flavorful.
- Family-Friendly Options: With a variety of dishes suitable for both kids and adults, it's a go-to spot for family outings.
- Convenience: Whether you prefer to dine in, take out, or enjoy the lovely outdoor seating, Mystic Market has you covered.
Each dish bursts with flavor, making it a delight for food enthusiasts. Their dedication to quality ingredients and a welcoming atmosphere shines through every meal, leaving diners eager to return. Experience the magic of Mystic Market Kitchen and Eatery!
Custom Sandwiches
A Make Your Own
Falafel Hummus Wrap
Our housemade hummus and falafel rolled in a spinach wrap with leaf lettuce, fresh tomatoes, red onions, sweet and spicy pickles, daikon radish pickles and tzatziki
Italian Combo
Ham, hot coppa, genoa salami and provolone with roasted red peppers, lettuce, tomatoes and balsamic on our freshly baked baguette, served cold
Green Monster
Allnatural roasted turkey, green goddess dressing, cucumbers, baby spinach, avocado, and pepper jack cheese on fresh sourdough bread
Jammin Turkey
Roasted turkey, cheddar, bacon jam, lettuce, tomato, cranberry mayo on multigrain bread, served cold
Raging Bull
Our house roasted beef and aged cheddar with lettuce, tomato, red onion and horseradish mayo on a freshly baked baguette, served cold
Ham Brie
Black Forest Ham, Honey Cup Mustard, Brie, Lettuce Tomato on Mulitigrain Bread, served cold
Mediterranean Tuna Wrap
Solid White Tuna Salad, Lime Cucumbers, Olive Tapenade, Arugula Roasted Red Peppers in a Tomato Wrap, served cold
California Chicken
Grilled Chicken Breast, Dill Havarti, Bacon, Avocado, Baby Greens, Tomatoes Chipotle Aioli served Hot Toasty on a French Roll
Mystic Cheesesteak
Our Juicy Smoked Beef Brisket topped with Melted Provolone, Peppers, Onions Black Garlic Aioli served Hot Toasty on a French Roll
Mystic Meatball
House Made Meatballs, Mozzarella, Banana Peppers, Pomodoro served Hot Toasty on a Garlic Bread French Roll
Big Buffalo
Crispy Chicken Breast, Spicy Buffalo Wing Sauce, Cheddar, Shaved Celery Blue Cheese Dressing Served on served Hot Toasty on a French Roll
BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich
Our Flavorful Pulled Pork, BBQ, Cheddar, Banana Peppers, Red Onion Crunchy Slaw served Hot Toasty on a French Roll
Crispy Eggplant Sandwich
Crispy eggplant, arugula, ricotta,pesto mayo and roasted red peppers served Hot Toasty on a French Roll
Chicken Parmesan
Crispy Panko Chicken, Pomodoro Shredded Mozzarella served Hot Toasty on a French Roll
Italian Chicken
Grilled Chicken Breast, Roasted Tomatoes, Fresh Mozzarella Pesto Mayo served Hot Toasty on a French Roll
Artisanal Sandwiches
Paninis Grilled Sandwiches
Bronx Bomber
HouseSmoked Brisket, Swiss Cheese, Caramelized Onions, Dill Pickles Grainy Mustard on Rye Bread served hot from the panini press
Roasted Turkey
Roasted Butternut Squash, Sharp Cheddar, Red Onion Marmalade Cranberry Mayo on Multigrain Bread served hot from the panini press
House Roast Beef
Gorgonzola, Caramelized Onions, Arugula Black Garlic Aioli on Grilled Flatbread served hot from the panini press
Roasted Portobello
Portobello Mushroom with Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato Arugula Pesto Mayo on Grilled Focaccia served hot from the panini press
Pressed Prosciutto
Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato, Arugula Pesto Mayo on Grilled Flatbread served hot from the panini press
Grilled Chicken Provolone
Roasted Red Peppers, Baby Spinach Pesto Aioli served hot from the panini press
Flame Grilled Chicken
Sliced Chicken, Smoked Gouda, Arugula, Roasted Red Peppers Garlic Aioli on Sour Dough Bread served hot from the panini press
Crispy Cauliflower Burrito
Crispy Cauliflower, Vegan Cheddar, Cowboy Caviar, Pico de Gallo, Avocado, Vegan Chipotle Ranch, Tomato Wrap served hot from the panini press
Grilled Cheese
Gooey Cheese on sourdough served hot from the panini press
Fish Tacos
Fried Cod, Chipotle Aioli, Salsa Verde, Shredded Lettuce Pineapple Cucumber Slaw in White Tortillas
Fenwick Tuna Melt
Solid White Tuna Salad, Baby Arugula, Cheddar Tomatoes on Rye Bread served hot from the panini press
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken Breast, Green Leaf Lettuce, Caesar Dressing, Shredded Parmesan Croutons on a White Wrap
Caprese
Roasted Tomatoes, Pesto, Balsamic Fig Glaze, Fresh Mozzarella Arugula on Grilled Flatbread, served hot from the panini press
Chicken Salad Wrap
Mystic Market Chicken Salad, Lettuce Tomato on a White Wrap, Served Cold
Tuna Salad Wrap
Solid White Tuna Salad, Lettuce Tomato on a Wheat Wrap, served cold
Classic Cuban
Roasted Pork, Black Forest Ham, Swiss Cheese, Dill Pickles, Spicy Green Sauce Dijon Mustard on a Toasted Baguette served hot from the panini press
California BLT
Crispy bacon, bacon jam, avocado, lettuce, tomato, and black garlic aioli on fresh sourdough bread
Signature Sandwiches
Special Sandwiches
Chicken Burrito
Crab Cake Sandwich
Mystic Market Crab Cakes on a Grilled Flatbread with Arugula, Tomatoes, Cole Slaw Chipotle Aioli
Kids Grilled Cheese
Kids PBJ
Spanakopita Each
Buttery Flakey Phyllo Dough with Spinach Feta
The Rachel Turkey Reuben
Turkey, Sauerkraut , Russian Dressing Swiss on Rye
Pepsi
The bold, refreshing, robust cola, click to add to your meal.
Diet Pepsi
A crisp tasting, refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without calories. Click to add to your meal.
Pepsi Zero
Real cola taste, with a refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without sugar. Click to add to your meal.
Mountain Dew
Mtn Dew exhilarates and quenches thirst with its one of a kind citrus taste. Click to add to your meal.
Starry
A caffeinefree soda that provides a crisp, clear burst of lemon lime flavor. Click to add to your meal.
Aquafina Water
Pure water for a perfect taste. Add a refreshing water to your meal.
Pureleaf Iced Tea Lemonade
Start with freshpicked leaves brewed just right, add lemon for balance and finish it with real sugar. Click to add to your meal.
Pureleaf Unsweetened Green Iced Tea
The crisp, clean taste of green tea brewed and bottled without adding sugar or color. Click to add to your meal.
CELSIUS Grape Rush
this carbonated flavor of CELSIUS has the perfect balance of flavor and energy. Click to add to your meal.
Tropicana Orange Juice
A juice drink with the delicious orange taste you love and the vitamin C nutrition you need. Click to add to your meal.
Bubly Grapefruit
Grapefruit flavored sparkling water no calories, no sweeteners, all smiles. Click to add to your meal.
Bubly Blackberry
Blackberry flavored sparkling water no calories, no sweeteners, all smiles. Click to add to your meal.
Beverages
Salads
Market Salad
Fresh Greens, Your Choice of Goat Cheese or Gorgonzola Cheese, Toasted Spiced Walnuts, Dried Cranberries, your choice of Dressing
Greek Salad
Romaine, Tomatoes, Feta, Cucumbers, Banana Peppers, Kalamata Olives, Red Onions, Greek Lemon Vinaigrette
Classic Caesar Salad
Crisp Romaine, Herb Croutons, Shredded Parmesan our Classic Caesar Dressing
Chopped Cobb Salad
Romaine and Fresh Greens, Crumbled Bacon, Turkey, Hard Boiled Egg, Cherry Tomatoes and Gorgonzola with a Balsamic Vinaigrette
Fresh Garden Salad
Fresh Greens, Tomatoes, Carrots, Cucumbers, Sweet Red Peppers Balsamic Vinaigrette
Southwest Chicken Salad
Spiced Chicken over Romaine with Grape Tomatoes, Cowboy Caviar, Fresh Avocado, Cheddar, Tortilla Strips, Vegan Chipotle Ranch Dressing